nimbletoad blog

I want to thank Alder Yarrow, Founder of Hydrant and creator of Vincellar, for his response to my previous post on Web Applications.  He summed up a few points about the web application, Vincellar, much more succinctly than I could.  He wrote,

“[Vincellar] would never have generated the revenues required to justify the investment made in its creation and redesign… Vincellar was merely a value add service…”

The financial decision to build a web application whether it be a stand alone service, or “merely a value add service” needs to be weighed against the  potential benefits it will bring to both the company and its clients.  For Vinfolio the financial decision to redesign Vincellar was to be offset by the added revenue generated by the marketplace.  Vincellar did not directly cause Vinfolio’s financial troubles, but it possible that it is endemic of the financial spend that led to the company’s downfall.

Wild hypothesis.  Vincellar turned Vinfolio upside down.  When a new client signed up for Vincellar the primary service they received was a great place to store and keep track of their wines (for free).  The value add to a new client was that they could also sell and buy wines in the marketplace.  While I do not want to conjecture how much Vinfolio paid for the redesign and daily management of the Vincellar application, it is clear that a significant amount of money was spent on this service.

Vinfolio’s core clients are active wine buyers, collectors and investors.  They routinely buy and sell wine.  Vincellar’s redesign was intended to expand this customer base, bring in new buyers and sellers.  They problem was that not only did the core clients slow their purchasing, most of the new clients saw the primary benefit of the Vincellar system as a place to keep track of their wines.

In contrast, CellarTracker’s primary purpose is a place for users to keep track of their wines and tasting notes; the ability to sell wines was recently added as a “value add.”  I greatly admire Eric Levine’s work with CellarTracker.  Out of his love for wine and his desire to build a cellar management program for himself, he has defined online cellar management.  Eric has spent thousands of hours on this web application, hours which he may or may not every financially recoup.  CellarTracker is his baby and seeing it grow and mature is Eric’s main reward. This fact in-itself ensures CellarTracker’s continued existence.

To companies – “Value Add” web services are a great way to build leads and expand a customer base.  However, the “Value Add” should not become a service in itself.  Otherwise there is a risk that the free value add will become the primary business to the new client base.  If Vincellar  is on one extreme, a mortgage calculator on a realtor’s site is another.  The mortgage calculator is handy, will never overshadow the realtor’s house listing, but will not generate that many new clients.  My advice, find somewhere in the middle.

Disclosure – We are currently working on a cellar management solution called Vinecat.  We have been working on it for the last couple of years.  Like Eric’s CellarTracker it is a labor of love.  I currently use it to keep track of my wine cellar and love its simplicity.  We think the general public would also like to use this system.  As cellar solutions such a CellarTracker and Vincellar get more complex, we feel there is a growing need for a simpler solution.  When will it be released?  We don’t know. Will it make money? Maybe.

I watched a documentary tonight about Dorian Paskowitz and his family. One quote by him particularly rang true.

“In early times man fought to save himself from hunger. Today we fight to be hungry”

As designers and creators of today’s consumer marketplace we have to ask ourselves, “What do people really want.” I cannot help but remember what Alex Bogusky once said to me, “why don’t you go low res? I’m sick of hi res.”

Yesterday, Apple premiered the IPad. Today, the press is declaring it a flop.

Is it being panned because people want to prove that they are still hungry?

VinFolio’s recent financial troubles bring up some legitimate concerns for Web Application pricing models.  Too often web applications are built without consideration for sustainable revenue or long term impact on the user community.  Many companies such as Vinfolio built web applications as lead generation devices.  This method is wrong and too often ends badly when the generated leads fail to provide the anticipated revenue.

Like many web applications, VinFolio does not charge customers to sign up and use their cellar management tool,  VinCellar.  Customers can use this application to keep track of the wines in their wine cellar, receive real time cellar price evaluations, and interact with the VinCellar wine community.  Why does VinFolio offer all this functionality free of charge?  VinCellar is VinFolio’s lead generation device for wine storage and their wine auction marketplace.  VinFolio pays its bills and payroll through commission on wine sales.

Sounds like a win win.  VinFolio gets a steady flow of wines to sell and wine collectors get a great application to manage their cellars free of charge.

Not so fast.  What happens if wines stop selling? What is the price of free?  Now that Vinfolio is circling the financial drain, the future of VinCellar is in jeopardy.

VinCellar clients have invested many hours inputting wines into this system and adding tasting notes.

Vinfolio is not in the business of providing cellar management.  The web app was a fancy lead generation front. VinFolio gave the service away in the hopes of profiting from the sale of the user’s wines.  The problem is that the commission did not pay the rent.

VinCellar is a case of different primary benefits between the site owners and its users.

Users:
Primary – Keeping track of their wine cellars
Secondary – Interacting with the Wine Collector Community
Convenience – An easy way to sell wine

VinFolio:
Primary – Selling users wines through the marketplace and auctions
Secondary – Storing user’s wines for a fee

Unlike other sites such as Ebay and Amazon where the users and site owner share common primary goals, VinFolio’s goals were not aligned with its users.

At Nimbletoad, we firmly believe that a site’s goals should be aligned with the users of that site.  Web Applications  should derive their sustainability from the user community.  This can come either from subscription revenue as in the case of BaseCamp or Freshbooks, or from advertising such as Facebook and Myspace.

Just 120 days after launch, Caimeiju.com’s Google Pagerank has grown from a rank of 0 to a rank of 4.  This rapid rank increase stands testament to Nimbletoad’s functional site design built upon sound search engine optimization tactics.

Google’s Pagerank is based on a logarithmic scale.  So, the differences between levels gets geometrically greater as you go up the scale.  We get a lesson in logarithmic scales every time there is a major earthquake. Newsrooms around the world bring on experts to demonstrate how much greater a 4.0 earthquake is on the Richter scale than a 3.0.

Nimbletoad unveils caimeiju.com, a powerful web-based research tool built on the open source Content Management System Joomla!, utilizing the JoomlaWorks K2 content creation component and JPGraphs Object-Oriented PHP Graph creating library.

By integrating these tools, we were able to develop this site for our client Language Media Agency at a fraction of what proprietary technology would have cost. Caimeju.com shows the power CMS systems have beyond a basic website. Open source CMS systems, like Joomla! can be used to build dynamic web applications that stand along side some of the best proprietary software on the web.

By using JPGraphs, we were able to render statistical graphs on the fly in PNG format, allowing for a much faster display of the community data. Users are able to access the information without the constraints or need to install proprietary tools such as Adobe Flash on their web browser. Caimeiju.com is one of the most robust real estate tools that can be viewed on smart phones such as Apple’s iPhone and RIM’s Blackberry. Users of the iPhone and other smart phones can view the site and graphs without waiting for Adobe Flash to be available on their devices.

Caimeiju.com is a landmark real estate research tool, targeting Chinese Real Estate buyers in the US market. Caimeiju’s community data spans 1700 California cites, with plans to expand service to additional regions in the future.

I just wanted to take moment before I dive into the subject of art and functionality to introduce myself. My name is Nicole Schmidt and I’m Nimbletoad’s newest addition to the team. I’m here to offer design support and maintenance to the everyday operations. I’m excited to join the team in forging new media trails. When I’m not updating and developing sites my passion is creating art with my hands instead of a computer. Here is a a look at my offline passion.
_________

Visual art, in the traditional sense, is simply mechanical reproduction. In the days of the masters it literally was reproduction because copying someone else is how people learned how to create art. Even with today’s modern and contemporary art movements visual art is still an imitation of nature, imitation of fantasy, interpretation of other peoples art or an attempt to be original through circumstance. So if visual art is subjective and functional art like the Taj Mahal is objective how can you have functional visual art?

I think my form of art is the pinnacle of functional static 2D art. I say this because my art is not just an expression of mine it is a product of repurposing. I take paper trash and recycle it to create my art. It’s one step further in getting the most functionality out of something that originally was made to have one function. Would someone know the original function of my materials was to report on the latest printed news or to inform the recipient their APR was being increased to 29%? Probably not but then again that is what I was going for, art made from trash that didn’t look like it was made from trash.

Some art purists may say it matters what the art was created with, a true artisan uses only the finest materials. For them art is not that subjective and they hold fast to a certain set of beliefs, this is what brings them to their opinions of what fine art is. It’s ok they can stay in the stone ages where functionality and art were two separate entities I myself will keep forging ahead carving new paths for those that follow.

My art is on display at Vine To Glass, 210-A N. Coast Hwy., Oceanside, CA 92054 through August 8, 2009. Come for the last hurrah with my art on the walls: Sun & Sea, Vino & Tapas at 6:30 p.m., Vine to Glass & Vigilucci’s Present the following pairings:

• Bailly Lapierre Blanc Brut Reserve, Cremant de Bourgognepaired with Endivia e Salmone Affumicato (Endive and smoked salmon)
  
• Venica Jesera Pinot Grigio paired with Prosciutto e Melone (Parma Prosciutto and Cantaloupe)
  
• Casa Barranca Red Blend paired with Involtini di Melanzane (Eggplant stuffed with wun dried tomatoes, goat cheese and basil)
  
• Ramos Pinto Ruby Port paired with Tartine alla frutta (Mini fruit tarts)

Cost is $35. Please RSVP to (760) 757-1037 or via email at tastings@vinetoglass.com no later than 5pm on August 6th.